Hey y'all! So... can we talk about something that's been driving me absolutely CRAZY lately? I keep seeing all these beautiful upcycled furniture pieces on social media, and then I talk to customers who are like "Mandy, I tried that and it was a disaster!"
And honestly? I get it. I've been there too... more times than I'd like to admit. Like, there was this one time I bought what I thought was going to be the PERFECT vintage dresser, and... well, let's just say it ended up as firewood. Not my finest moment, but hey - that's how we learn, right?
So today I'm sharing the 7 biggest mistakes I see people making with upcycled furniture projects (and trust me, I've made most of these myself). Plus, I'll tell you exactly how to fix them so you don't have to learn the hard way like I did!
## Mistake #1: Falling in Love with Pieces That Can't Be Saved
Oh my goodness, this one gets me EVERY time! You walk into a thrift store or estate sale, and you see this gorgeous piece that just speaks to your soul. The price is right, the bones look good from a distance... and then you get it home and realize it's basically held together with hopes and dreams.
I cant tell you how many times I've done this! There was this beautiful antique vanity I bought last year - I mean, it had THE most gorgeous curves and details. But when I actually started working on it? The wood was so rotted that my screwdriver went right through it like butter. BUTTER, y'all!
**Here's how to avoid this heartbreak:** Before you buy ANYTHING, give it the "shake test." Seriously. Gently wobble it, open and close the drawers, check for loose joints. If it feels like it might fall apart in your hands, walk away. I know it's hard... but trust me on this one.
Also, look for pieces made from real wood, not that particle board stuff. You can usually tell by the weight - real wood has some heft to it. And don't be afraid to ask questions! Most sellers know if something has issues.
## Mistake #2: Jumping in Without Doing Your Homework
Okay, so this is where I get a little preachy... but stick with me! I see SO many people who get excited about a project and just dive right in without any research. And look, I'm all for enthusiasm - believe me! But a little planning goes a long way.
I learned this lesson the hard way when I tried to refinish my kitchen table without knowing what type of wood it was. Spoiler alert: different woods need different treatments, and I basically ruined the finish. Had to start over completely... which wasn't fun.
**The fix?** Spend some time on Pinterest, YouTube, wherever! Look up the specific type of piece you're working on. Learn about the wood type, the best techniques for your desired finish, what tools you'll need. I promise it's worth the time upfront!
And hey, if you're working with chalk paint (which I LOVE - we carry the full [Annie Sloan line](https://www.themustardseedcollection.com/collections/annie-sloan) if you need supplies), do some research on different application techniques. There's so much more to it than just slapping paint on!
## Mistake #3: Skipping the Prep Work (The Biggest Sin!)
Ugh, okay... this one is my biggest pet peeve. And I say that as someone who HATES prep work! Like, seriously - I just want to get to the fun painting part, you know?
But here's the thing... and I learned this after many, MANY failed projects... the prep work is literally everything. It's the difference between a piece that looks professionally done and one that looks... well, like a DIY disaster.
I remember this one chair I was working on - beautiful Windsor chair, gorgeous lines. I was so excited to paint it that I barely sanded it. Just did a quick once-over and started painting. Y'all... that paint started peeling off within a week. A WEEK!
**Here's what you actually need to do:** Sand everything. Even if it looks clean, sand it. Remove old hardware. Fill any holes or scratches. Clean off all the dust. I know it's boring, but this step makes or breaks your project.
Pro tip: Get yourself some good sandpaper and don't cheap out. Trust me on this - your future self will thank you!
## Mistake #4: Using the Wrong Products (Been There!)
Oh honey... the amount of money I've wasted on cheap paint and supplies over the years! I used to think "paint is paint," and boy was I wrong.
There was this beautiful little end table I was working on - found it at an estate sale for like $10. I was so proud of myself! Then I went to the hardware store and bought the cheapest paint I could find because, you know, I was trying to keep costs down. Bad idea. SO bad.
The paint didn't cover evenly, it took forever to dry, and it never really hardened properly. Every time I put something on that table, it would stick slightly. Not exactly the look I was going for!
**The solution:** Invest in quality products from the start. Yes, good paint costs more upfront, but you'll use less of it, get better coverage, and the finish will actually last.
If you're using chalk paint, make sure you're getting the real deal - not just any paint labeled "chalk paint." There's a huge difference! And don't forget about proper brushes, primers if needed, and quality protective topcoats.
## Mistake #5: Underestimating What You're Getting Into
Okay, real talk... I am TERRIBLE at estimating how long projects will take. Like, embarrassingly bad. I'll think something will take a weekend, and three weeks later I'm still working on it.
But it's not just about time - it's about understanding what repairs are actually needed. That "little touch-up" can turn into a full restoration real quick!
I once bought this adorable little chest of drawers that just needed "a little love." Well, turns out it needed new drawer slides, the veneer was peeling in multiple places, and one of the legs was cracked. What I thought would be a quick weekend project turned into a month-long ordeal.
**How to avoid this:** Really examine pieces before you commit. Look for structural issues, water damage, missing hardware. And when you're planning your timeline? Double it. Seriously. Then you'll either finish early (which feels amazing) or you'll be realistic about what you're taking on.
Also, be honest about your skill level. There's no shame in passing on a project that's beyond your current abilities. You can always come back to more challenging pieces as you gain experience!
## Mistake #6: Cutting Corners on Tools and Supplies
Y'all... I have made this mistake SO many times. Like, I'll spend good money on quality paint and then use a cheap brush from the dollar store. Or I'll buy just barely enough sandpaper thinking I can make it work.
Spoiler alert: it doesn't work! I learned this lesson when I was refinishing a beautiful vintage dresser and ran out of paint halfway through. The color I'd mixed was custom, so I couldn't just run to the store and get more. Had to start over with the entire piece because I couldn't match the color exactly.
**Here's what I've learned:** Buy more supplies than you think you need. Seriously. Paint, sandpaper, brushes - get extra. It's better to have leftovers than to be stuck in the middle of a project.
And invest in decent tools! You don't need the most expensive stuff, but get brushes that won't leave streaks and bristles all over your work. Your future self will thank you, I promise.
## Mistake #7: Losing Steam When Things Get Tough
Okay, this one hits close to home because I struggle with it ALL the time. You start a project all excited and motivated, and then you hit a snag. Maybe the paint isn't going on right, or you discover damage you didn't see before, or it's just taking way longer than expected.
And then what happens? The piece sits in your garage or basement for months while you avoid dealing with it. Been there? Yeah, me too. I currently have TWO pieces in various stages of "I'll get back to it someday."
**The reality check:** Not every piece needs to be perfect! Sometimes "good enough" really is good enough, especially when you're learning. I had to give myself permission to not be a perfectionist, and it was honestly liberating.
Also, remember why you started the project in the first place. Was it to save money? Create something unique? Learn a new skill? Keep that motivation in mind when things get frustrating.
And hey, if you really get stuck, there's no shame in asking for help or even selling the piece as-is to someone else who might have the skills or motivation to finish it.
## The Bottom Line (Because I Know You're Busy!)
Look, upcycling furniture isn't always easy, but it's SO rewarding when you get it right. And the mistakes? They're just part of the learning process. I've probably made every mistake in the book, and I'm still here telling you about it!
The key is to start small, be patient with yourself, and don't be afraid to ask questions. Whether you're shopping for supplies at The Mustard Seed Collection
https://www.themustardseedcollection.com or just need some advice, remember that we're all learning together.
And honestly? Some of my favorite pieces came from projects where everything went wrong initially. There's something to be said for pieces with character and stories behind them!
What's your biggest upcycling disaster story? I'd love to hear about it - makes me feel better about my own mistakes! Drop me a line and let's commiserate together.
){kind=link}